A good school-supplies deal is not simply the largest pack or the lowest checkout price. I rank the BIC Xtra-Smooth 10-Pack first because its manageable quantity, no-sharpening design, and versatile 0.7mm lead fit the widest range of students. The Amazon Basics 30-Pack is my value choice for buyers who want inexpensive traditional pencils, while the BIC Bright Edition 40-Pack offers the strongest bulk proposition for classrooms and multi-student households.
Get your next haul delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
The main choice is between mechanical convenience and wood-pencil simplicity. Mechanical pencils stay ready without a sharpener, but refills add another supply to manage. Wood-cased pencils are familiar, widely accepted, and easy to distribute, yet they become shorter and need regular sharpening. Young children have a separate need: the thick lead and triangular body of the Paper Mate option provide more control than either BIC model. I ordered these picks by likely value for the stated buyer, pack usefulness, school suitability, and the risk of paying for units that will sit unused.
Key Takeaways
- The amazon.com/dp/B00260X7F2?tag=reviewsmill.com-20&ascsubtag=dc-636495″ target=”_blank” rel=”nofollow sponsored noopener”>BIC Xtra-Smooth 10-Pack ranks first because ten refillable 0.7mm pencils balance useful quantity, everyday versatility, and minimal storage.
- The Amazon Basics 30-Pack is the stronger budget choice when a class requires traditional pre-sharpened #2 HB pencils.
- The BIC Bright Edition 40-Pack makes more sense for teachers and large households than for one student, even when its unit price is low.
- Paper Mate’s 1.3mm lead and triangular barrels suit developing handwriting better than the thinner, round BIC pencils.
- Ticonderoga is the quality-led wood-pencil pick, but buyers should compare its live pack count and unit price against Amazon Basics before ordering.
| school supplies deal | Pencil type | Pack count | Lead grade | Lead size |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BIC Xtra-Smooth Mechanical Pen | Mechanical graphite | 10 | No. 2 | 0.7mm |
| Amazon Basics Wood-Cased #2 HB | Wood-cased graphite | 30 | #2 HB | — |
| BIC Xtra Smooth Bright Edition | Mechanical graphite | 40 | No. 2 | 0.7mm |
| Paper Mate Handwriting Triangu | Mechanical graphite | 5 | HB | 1.3mm |
| Ticonderoga Wood-Cased Pencils | Wood-cased graphite | Verify on current listing | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
BIC Xtra-Smooth Mechanical Pencils, Medium Point, 0.7mm, 10-Count Pack
I rank the BIC Xtra-Smooth 10-Pack first because it offers the best balance of quantity, convenience, and broad school usefulness. Ten pencils are enough to divide between a backpack, desk, pencil case, and homework area without turning a modest purchase into classroom inventory. The 0.7mm No. 2 lead produces a more forgiving line than fine 0.5mm lead and works for notes, worksheets, math, and many standardized-test requirements.
Compared with the BIC Bright Edition 40-Pack, this pack asks for less money upfront and wastes less storage space. Both provide the same basic 0.7mm mechanical format, but the 40-pack earns its keep through scale rather than a better individual pencil. The 10-pack is also cleaner and more convenient than Amazon Basics wood pencils because clicking replaces sharpening. That difference matters during a timed class or when a student cannot readily access a sharpener.
The tradeoff is a plain, grip-free design. Paper Mate’s triangular barrels offer young writers better finger guidance, and Ticonderoga may feel more familiar to students who prefer wood. Eraser capacity is also limited by the narrow mechanical body. I would choose this deal for a typical middle-school, high-school, or college student, but not for a child learning pencil control or a classroom buyer who can use all 40 units of the larger BIC pack.
Pros:- Ten-count quantity suits one student better than a large classroom pack
- 0.7mm No. 2 lead handles notes, worksheets, and many test forms
- Smudge-resistant graphite erases cleanly
- Click advancement removes the need for a sharpener
Cons:- No contoured or cushioned grip
- Only one lead diameter and hardness are included
- Small built-in erasers may require separate replacements
Best for: Individual students who want a practical supply of everyday mechanical pencils without buying a classroom-size box
Not ideal for: Early writers who need a guided grip, or students who prefer fine lead and specialized graphite grades
- Pencil type:Mechanical graphite
- Lead size:0.7mm
- Lead grade:No. 2
- Pack count:10
- Graphite color:Black
- Point style:Medium
- Lead advancement:Click mechanism
- Clip style:Bright assorted colors
Our verdict“This is my top deal for most students because it combines a sensible pack size with reliable, sharpener-free writing.”
Amazon Basics Wood-Cased #2 HB School Pencils with Erasers, Pre-Sharpened, Orange, 30 Count
For buyers following a conventional classroom list, the Amazon Basics 30-Pack is my strongest value alternative. Its wood-cased #2 HB pencils arrive pre-sharpened and ready to distribute, avoiding the tedious setup associated with an unsharpened bulk box. Thirty units provide a useful reserve for lost pencils, broken tips, group projects, or more than one child.
This pack ranks above the 40-count BIC box for many families because traditional pencils need no proprietary mechanism or lead refill. A child can lend one out without much concern, and teachers can place several around a classroom. Against Ticonderoga, Amazon Basics leads on straightforward volume-oriented value. Ticonderoga counters with premium wood, a thicker graphite core, and a stronger quality reputation, so the better deal depends on the live price gap.
Wood pencils introduce recurring friction that the two BIC choices avoid: they need sharpening, produce shavings, and shrink with use. The round barrel has no ergonomic grip, making Paper Mate the more purposeful choice for early handwriting practice. I would also avoid treating the top eraser as a reason to skip a separate block eraser; frequent correction can wear a pencil-top eraser down long before the graphite is finished. This option wins when low-stress replacement and familiar classroom compatibility matter more than mechanical convenience.
Pros:- Thirty pencils provide useful household or classroom reserves
- Pre-sharpened tips save preparation time
- #2 HB graphite suits everyday writing and many school tests
- Latex-free top erasers are accessible to more students
Cons:- Periodic sharpening interrupts work and creates shavings
- Round barrels provide no finger guidance or added grip
- Wood pencils become shorter and less comfortable as they wear
Best for: Families and teachers seeking an affordable reserve of familiar, ready-to-use #2 wood pencils
Not ideal for: Students who cannot access a sharpener or who want a consistent mechanical point throughout the day
- Pencil type:Wood-cased graphite
- Lead grade:#2 HB
- Pack count:30
- Body color:Orange
- Body shape:Round
- Preparation:Pre-sharpened
- Eraser:Latex-free top eraser
- Dimensions:7.4 x 0.3 x 0.3 inches per pencil
Our verdict“Choose this pack when traditional #2 pencils are required and replacement-friendly quantity matters more than refined materials.”
BIC Xtra Smooth Bright Edition Mechanical Pencils, 0.7 mm, 40-Count Pack
The appeal of the BIC Bright Edition 40-Pack is scale. I place it third overall but first for classrooms because forty refillable pencils can stock shared desks, serve several children, or cover a teacher’s lending supply. The bright assorted barrels are easier to spot in crowded pencil cups than a set of identical muted pencils, while the retractable 0.7mm No. 2 format works across ordinary school subjects.
Its closest rival is the first-ranked BIC 10-pack. The writing proposition is similar, so a buyer should not assume the larger box brings a richer feature set. Instead, the decision comes down to unit price versus usable quantity. If the 40-pack costs less per pencil and most of the box will be used, it is the better deal. If pencils are likely to remain in a cabinet for years, the smaller pack keeps the purchase leaner.
Compared with Amazon Basics, these pencils avoid sharpening and retain their full barrel length. They do require spare lead and erasers, however, and the specification offers no contoured grip or reinforced writing tip. That makes the box less appealing for young children than Paper Mate, despite its cheerful colors. It is also easy for refillable pencils to become disposable in practice when students lose them. I recommend this pack only when the buyer has a clear distribution plan; the low cost per unit means little when much of the inventory goes untouched.
Pros:- Large quantity can produce a strong per-pencil price
- Refillable and retractable bodies extend practical use
- 0.7mm No. 2 lead is suitable for broad schoolwork
- Bright barrels help identify pencils in shared spaces
Cons:- Forty pencils are excessive for many individual buyers
- No dedicated grip or handwriting-guidance feature
- Refill lead and erasers create additional supply needs
Best for: Teachers, tutoring centers, and multi-student households that can put a 40-pencil supply into active use
Not ideal for: One student with limited storage or a young learner who needs a thicker lead and guided grip
- Pencil type:Mechanical graphite
- Edition:Bright Edition
- Lead size:0.7mm
- Lead grade:No. 2
- Pack count:40
- Refillable:Yes
- Retractable:Yes
- Intended users:Students and teachers
Our verdict“The 40-pack is a compelling bulk buy when every unit has a destination, but the smaller BIC pack is the smarter default for one student.”
Paper Mate Handwriting Triangular Mechanical Pencils with Lead & Eraser Refills, 1.3mm, Fun Barrel Colors, 5 Count
I rank the Paper Mate Handwriting 5-Pack by suitability rather than quantity. Each pencil uses thick 1.3mm HB lead, which is less prone to snapping under the uneven pressure common among developing writers. The triangular, contoured body encourages a more controlled finger position and resists rolling away, translating a basic shape choice into calmer handwriting practice.
Neither BIC pack serves this audience as directly. Their thinner 0.7mm lead supports neater notes for older students but can break more readily in a heavy hand, and their conventional barrels provide less placement guidance. Paper Mate also includes lead and eraser refills, adding value beyond the five-pencil count. For a kindergarten or early-elementary buyer, five appropriate tools can be a better deal than forty poorly matched ones.
This is a specialized purchase, which explains its fourth-place position. The broad line is less suitable for tiny math work, compact planners, technical drawing, or older students who want fine handwriting. Refills may also be less common than standard 0.7mm lead, so I would check local availability before depending on the pencils for a full school year. Amazon Basics wood pencils remain simpler to replace at short notice. Paper Mate deserves the premium when handwriting development is the goal, but buyers shopping only by unit count will find stronger value elsewhere.
Pros:- Triangular body guides finger placement and limits rolling
- Thick 1.3mm lead resists breakage under heavier pressure
- Included lead and eraser refills add immediate utility
- Bright barrel colors make practice more inviting for children
Cons:- Broad lines are poorly suited to compact or detailed writing
- 1.3mm refills may be harder to find than 0.7mm lead
- Five-count pack offers limited value for classroom distribution
Best for: Kindergarten and early-elementary students developing pencil control or frequently breaking thinner lead
Not ideal for: Older students writing in small spaces, technical classes, or households that cannot readily source 1.3mm refills
- Pencil type:Mechanical graphite
- Lead size:1.3mm
- Lead grade:HB
- Pack count:5
- Body shape:Triangular
- Grip:Contoured
- Hand orientation:Ambidextrous
- Included extras:Lead and eraser refills
- Barrel pattern:Assorted fun colors
Our verdict“This is the best targeted deal for early writers because its thick lead and triangular shape solve problems the higher-volume packs do not.”
Ticonderoga Wood-Cased Pencils, Pre-Sharpened
Ticonderoga Pre-Sharpened Pencils take the final position because this roundup prioritizes deal clarity and broad value, while their case rests on material quality. The exclusive #2 graphite formula and thicker core are designed for smooth, consistent marks. Premium wood sourced from responsibly managed forests may also sharpen more predictably than a bargain pencil made with less consistent casing material.
That makes Ticonderoga the quality-led counterpart to Amazon Basics. Amazon’s 30-count pack provides a clearly defined quantity and aims at economical replenishment; Ticonderoga is better suited to a buyer willing to pay more per pencil for graphite consistency and wood quality. Both arrive pre-sharpened and use latex-free erasers. Before purchasing, I would compare the active Ticonderoga listing’s exact count with Amazon’s price per pencil, since the supplied product information does not identify a pack size.
The familiar #2 format works for most school writing, but it cannot offer the never-sharpen convenience of either BIC pack or the finger guidance of Paper Mate. Buyers also receive no alternate graphite grades, barrel colors, or specialty accessories. The premium only pays back through daily writing quality, not added functions. I would pick Ticonderoga for a student who dislikes scratchy or inconsistent budget pencils; I would choose Amazon Basics when pencils are frequently lost, loaned, or consumed in large numbers.
Pros:- Exclusive #2 graphite formula targets smooth, consistent writing
- Thick core offers dependable lines
- Premium wood comes from responsibly managed forests
- Pre-sharpened, latex-free, and certified non-toxic
Cons:- Likely carries a higher per-pencil cost than basic wood options
- Requires sharpening throughout its useful life
- Listing quantity must be verified before comparing deal value
Best for: Students and families who prefer traditional pencils and will pay more for smoother graphite and responsibly sourced wood
Not ideal for: High-loss classrooms, bargain-first shoppers, or students who want a mechanical pencil with no sharpening
- Pencil type:Wood-cased graphite
- Graphite grade:Exclusive #2 formula
- Core:Thick graphite core
- Wood source:Responsibly managed forests
- Preparation:Pre-sharpened
- Eraser:Latex-free and securely glued
- Safety certification:PMA-certified non-toxic
- Pack count:Verify on current listing
Our verdict“Ticonderoga is the wood-pencil upgrade for buyers who value smoother construction, but its live unit price must justify the step above Amazon Basics.”
How We Picked
I treated these products as competing school-supplies deals, not as five interchangeable pencils. My ranking gives the most weight to the relationship between price, usable quantity, and the needs of a real buyer. A 40-count box may post the lowest cost per pencil, for example, but it is a weaker purchase for one student who needs only a few. I also examined whether each pack arrives ready for class, whether the pencil format matches common school assignments, and whether refills or sharpeners create extra costs.
I then separated everyday value from specialized value. The two BIC packs compete on quantity and storage; Amazon Basics and Ticonderoga compete on affordability versus material and graphite quality; Paper Mate earns its place through age-specific design rather than raw unit count. I favored #2 or HB graphite because it covers ordinary writing and many test forms, while recognizing that art students may need other hardness levels.
Prices can move throughout the back-to-school season, so I would check the current cost per usable pencil before buying. I also account for lead breakage, sharpening, eraser replacement, and the chance of losing supplies. The final order reflects broad buying value first, followed by traditional-pencil savings, bulk economics, early-writing support, and premium construction.
| school supplies deal | Pencil type | Lead grade |
|---|---|---|
| BIC Xtra-Smooth Mechanical Pen | Mechanical graphite | No. 2 |
| Amazon Basics Wood-Cased #2 HB | Wood-cased graphite | #2 HB |
| BIC Xtra Smooth Bright Edition | Mechanical graphite | No. 2 |
| Paper Mate Handwriting Triangu | Mechanical graphite | HB |
| Ticonderoga Wood-Cased Pencils | Wood-cased graphite | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing School Supplies Deals
I would start a school-pencil purchase with the student’s daily work and only then compare discounts. The right deal supplies a useful amount of the right pencil; the wrong one converts a low unit price into clutter, breakage, or an extra shopping trip.
Compare Cost Per Usable Pencil
A large pack often advertises the lowest price per pencil, but I also ask how many units will realistically be used. The BIC 40-pack has stronger bulk potential than its 10-pack sibling, while the smaller box limits upfront spending for one student. For wood pencils, I would divide the live price by the exact count and account for breakage or inconsistent sharpening. A slightly dearer pencil that writes predictably can still be the better value for daily assignments.
Match the Pencil Format to the Classroom
Mechanical pencils provide consistent barrel length and click advancement, making them convenient for note-heavy students. Some teachers or test instructions may prefer traditional #2 pencils, in which case Amazon Basics or Ticonderoga is the safer purchase. I would check the supply list before choosing. A mechanical bargain loses its appeal if it remains at home during testing, while a wood pencil becomes inconvenient when no sharpener is available.
Choose Lead Thickness by Writing Stage
0.7mm lead balances durability and line control for general schoolwork, which helps both BIC packs serve older students. Paper Mate’s 1.3mm lead creates a broader mark but tolerates more pressure, making it better for children still learning control. I would not choose the thick option solely because it breaks less; crowded equations and small notebook ruling favor a narrower point. Artists may need multiple hardness grades beyond every #2 or HB option here.
Account for Supporting Supplies
The purchase price does not capture every cost. Wood pencils need a dependable sharpener, and mechanical pencils eventually need compatible lead and erasers. Paper Mate includes starter refills, though its 1.3mm size may be less convenient to replace than BIC’s common 0.7mm lead. I would add those supporting items to the basket total before declaring a winner. Separate block erasers are also useful when frequent corrections could exhaust small pencil-top erasers.
Buy for Loss, Sharing, and Storage
School pencils disappear, get loaned, and migrate between rooms. A modest reserve prevents emergency replacements, but an oversized package can occupy space without saving practical money. The 40-count BIC and 30-count Amazon Basics packs work well in shared environments. Ten BIC pencils better fit one organized student, and five Paper Mate pencils suit a child who uses the same specialized design each day. I would label reusable mechanical pencils when loss is common.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are mechanical pencils allowed for school tests?
Rules vary by teacher and testing program, so I would read the instructions for the specific exam. Both BIC products use No. 2 graphite, but the correct graphite grade does not automatically mean a mechanical pencil is accepted. When directions explicitly request a wood-cased #2 pencil, Amazon Basics or Ticonderoga removes uncertainty. Keeping two pre-sharpened wood pencils available is a low-cost backup even for a student who normally prefers mechanical models.
Is a 40-count pencil pack a better deal than a 10-count pack?
It is better only when the unit price is lower and most pencils will be used. A teacher, tutoring center, or large household can spread the BIC Bright Edition pack across many desks, making its scale useful. One student may receive better practical value from the 10-pack because it costs less upfront and is easier to store. I would compare live prices, divide by count, and then discount any quantity likely to remain unused.
Which pencil is best for a child learning to write?
I favor the Paper Mate Handwriting pencil for a developing writer. Its triangular body provides a physical cue for finger placement, and the 1.3mm lead handles heavy pressure better than the 0.7mm lead in both BIC packs. The broad point is less useful once schoolwork moves toward compact writing and detailed math. At that stage, the child can move to a standard mechanical pencil or a sharpened wood-cased #2 model.
Are pre-sharpened pencils worth paying extra for?
Pre-sharpening is most valuable when a pack must be handed out immediately. The Amazon Basics and Ticonderoga pencils arrive ready for a first lesson, test, or homework session, saving setup time for a teacher or parent. I would not pay a large premium for that feature alone because every wood pencil still needs sharpening later. Construction quality, graphite consistency, pack count, and current price should carry more weight in the final choice.
When is Ticonderoga worth more than Amazon Basics?
Ticonderoga makes more sense when the buyer values smoother graphite, a thick core, and premium wood enough to accept a possible price increase. Those qualities may improve daily writing and sharpening consistency, while Amazon Basics focuses on economical quantity. I would choose Amazon Basics for lending supplies or frequent losses. For a student who keeps track of pencils and notices scratchy graphite, Ticonderoga has a clearer path to earning its higher cost.
Conclusion
For most individual students, I recommend the BIC Xtra-Smooth 10-Pack; it provides enough backups without forcing a bulk purchase, and its 0.7mm No. 2 lead suits varied schoolwork. Buyers who need traditional pencils at a value-led price should choose the Amazon Basics 30-Pack. Teachers and large households can justify the BIC Bright Edition 40-Pack when its lower unit cost applies to pencils that will actually be distributed.
For a young child building handwriting control, I would bypass the higher-ranked general-purpose choices and buy Paper Mate Handwriting pencils. Their thick lead and triangular shape address that buyer’s needs more directly. Ticonderoga is my recommendation for the student who prefers wood pencils and values smoother graphite over the lowest possible unit price. Whichever role fits, I would compare the live pack price, exact quantity, and refill or sharpening costs before checking out.
Evergreen bestsellers Picks
bestsellers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
